Site Highlights














« A floor wax & a dessert topping. | Main | Welcome to the new home of RawWorkflow.com »
Friday
12Sep

The proper time for multi-camera shoots.

Nikon GP-1 mounted on a D90We as photographers have a lot to think about when going out on a complex multi-camera shoot. Between getting all (and I mean all) the gear ready for that specific job, batteries fully charged up, enough memory cards pre-formatted (never format a card on the job, but that is the topic of another post), details of the job, enough sleep before, and sufficient caffeine during....well you know the drill. You get to the job and meet the other photographers, each shooting their own set of gear from all walks of life. You barely have time enough for hellos and to hand out assignments, and coverage duties, and you are all off, some shooting and some meeting with the clients (doing the schmooze). Oops, forgot the time-sync the cameras.

For anyone who shoots multiple camera jobs (even if it is just you and 2 cameras), it is a nightmare in post production if the cameras are not time-synced. Why? Because the edit is usually accomplished best and fastest if the pictures are in chronological order. If the cameras are not time synced (their clocks set to identical times) then the pictures will be somewheres between "grouped by camera" (based on their very different time settings) to intertwined in a global mess (if their clock settings were off by smaller increments of time). It is much better if the clocks on non synced multiple cameras were more than n  (with n being the length of the shoot + 1 second). That gives you the group by camera effect. If the clocks are only seconds apart (more likely), then the post production person has many scenes from the job with the shots from the different cameras interspersed and the events appearing to be in some weird and random order.

Of course this all assumes that the different cameras are shooting the same scene, and not 2 different scenes at the same time. In the latter case, one has to take on a different strategy of sorting the files first by camera or photographer, and then chronologically.

 

How to time sync multiple cameras

 

  • Have everyone get together in a giant circle, check your cell phone for the proper time (exact time is not crucial in this method), and all hit the SET button at the same time (maybe someone could yell out "set!"). Not a bad method. It is accurate to within a second or so, but is somewhat hard to do if anyone has more than one camera to set. Also subject to user error. Like forgetting to also set the correct day.
  • Pass around a cell phone (or digital watch), and have everyone set their own cameras to the reference time. Not bad, but takes a lot of time, and subject to user error.
  • Have everyone take a shot of the same very recognizable subject at the exact same moment (someone could yell "click!). Does not set the clock, but creates a slate sync (like a clap stick on a movie set) such that all of the files from all of the cameras can be time-slipped in post production based on the sync frame from each camera. Very quick on the job and a good thing to do even if you have set the clocks, but a lot of work in post.

 

or, use the high tech magic bullet

 

If each camera is equipped with a GPS system, a common (international) time base is applied to the EXIF data of all captures, and without intervention or remembering to set the clock, any number of cameras can be time-synced together. In fact once all camera have GPS on-board (not too far away), there will be no more need to set the clock because the time will be derived from the GPS satellite signal. The clock is set by the GPS magician who live on the International Time Line.

What triggered this post was Nikon's announcement of its new GP-1 GPS adapter which can be used on most any of its recent digital cameras. Below are the details courtesy of Imaging-Resource.

 

The Nikon GP-1 is a little gadget that mounts on the hot shoe, and plugs into a new, dedicated GPS port on the side of the camera, using the GP1-CA90 accessory terminal cord. (While it's being announced with the D90, the GP-1 can also be used with the D3, D300, D700, D2x, D2xs, D2Hs, and D200 by plugging it into the 10-pin accessory terminal on those cameras, using the GP1-CA10 accessory terminal cord.) We haven't yet seen a sample of the GP-1, but it sounds relatively compact, at 1.97 x 1.79 x 1.00 inches (50 x 45.5 x 25.5mm). Power comes from the camera body, but we don't yet know how big an effect it will have on camera battery life. When operating, the GP-1 will copy latitude, longitude, altitude and time data into the EXIF headers of any image files captured. At this point, we have very little information on the GP-1 (including its projected price in the US), but one spec caught our eye: The GP-1 on average requires only 35 seconds for satellite acquisition, only 5 seconds from a hot start. That "hot start" seems tied to a setting on the setup menu for the GPS: You can apparently set it up to power-down whenever the camera's exposure meter shuts off. This could potentially save a lot of battery power, but at the relatively minor cost of needing to wait 5 seconds before snapping a shot after activating the camera's exposure meter, for the GPS unit to wake up. An interesting accessory, one we think will find a lot of application in various commercial, insurance, and governmental settings, where photos need to be authoritatively tagged with specific location information.

 


PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

References (1)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.
  • Response
    Response: New Nikons
    The SB- 400 gives photographers the opportunity to enjoy brighter and more natural lighting for images taken using a flash. It is designed to suit entry- level digital SLR users while also suitable for...

Reader Comments (7)

This is going to be a handy critter to have, especially if it can be retro fitted to the D2* series cameras through the accessory port.

I hope that they have other mounting options though - loosing the hotshoe means no GPS info when a flash needs to be deployed - this is going to limit its usefulness for some of us I think.

Sep 26, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterMichael Comerford

About sync of multiple cameras.... We have had this issue since 2001 when we started using two cameras on assignment (now generally 3 or 4 cameras!). At that time, there were no programs to blend the images by time(that we knew of). In '02 we discovered a little program called SuperJpeg which allowed 'sort by date created' and then a rename of all files kept them in order as long as..... you sync'd the cameras to start with and captured jpegs. That program is long gone and now we do our merge of raw files in Lightroom. If we forget for some reason prior to starting an assignment (has happened) or a year or something else is accidentally changed during a multi-camera sync, it's time consuming to find like files to resync. In reference to your statement about the "circle sync", the easiest way to find the time sync file from each camera is to shoot each other at the same time. Nothing is easier to find than a close-up of a person holding a camera aimed at a person holding a camera. "1, 2, 3, SHOOT" works flawlessly every time. It's a good idea to do it even when you have done a menu sync in case one camera is off.

Sep 29, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterJohn Tannock

Re: GP-1 for Nikons. While this unit will undoubtedly be very useful in many ways, having to mount it to the hot shoe renders the pop-up flash inoperable. Yeah, I know, who uses that anyway. Actually, it is very useful in commander mode to trigger other Nikon flashes or to have an SC-17 or other extension cord to trigger off-camera flashes. Also, does it "connect" through the electronics of the hot shoe, or is it just for placement?
Since it plugs into the accessory port on the camera, doesn't that also negate the use of a remote release cord while it's attached?

Sep 29, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterJohn Tannock

GPS solutions have existed for years, just lookup GPS +Nikon on Google. That said, the GPS information is written in special EXIF fields. The GPS time does not affects the standard "Date Taken" EXIF field, nor the file creation time, it definitely goes into the file's metadata, but on a different tag (at least that's how it work on current cameras I know, up to the D3 with 2.00 firmware).

The GPS time is expressed in UTC in 1 second increments, not enough to reliably sort multi-cameras 11fps sequences; you'd still get 1 second of "local randomness" in the merged sequence, provided that you find an application that can actually sort on the GPS time in the first place.

Also, sorting on an EXIF field requires a lot more work than simple file system level date/time sort, as each file must be opened and the metadata must be parsed to extract the time stamp. I made some tests for an app I’m writing and the initial “fetch & sort” time was more than 400 times slower.

A nice feature would be to be able to sync the camera's time to the GPS time. The hotshoe contacts are not used, you can velcro the GPS somewhere else, but in this case, beware that you lose the meaning of the "heading" information, that some GPS units provide and some cameras record. Heading can be useful in reconstructing 3D scenes shot from different angles.

Cheers,
Axel

Sep 29, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterAxel

I have also noticed that when sorting files in lightroom, the "sort by camera serial number" does not work with Nikon cameras (or Fuji DSLRs which are made under license by Nikon). When using 2 D300s, for instance, ALL D300 files are lumped together by camera model. When I questioned Nikon about this, I was told that the serial number data is in there, but a level lower than Lightroom reads, or something like that. I tried it with 2 Canons of the same model and it separated the files nicely.

Sep 30, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterJohn Tannock

I have this problem even on vacation -- if everybody in the family is not synched then when we load the pics and view by time order it doesn't make sense.

The solution is to sync all cameras to the RIGHT time -- e.g. the official standard time as defined by the atomic clock. How? By syncing with your computer. I'm on Windows but I'm sure the same must be true on Mac -- all Windows computers at least since XP have been syncing with atomic clocks via the sntp function on a daily basis.

Then plug in your camera via usb as a ptp device and click the Set Time button in the camera properties.

The only catch is P&S that can't do this -- or if timezones are set wrong on computer or camera. In which case it is back to manual!

Oct 5, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterRaymond

With Nikon cameras you can use Camera Control Pro to set the clocks based on the computer's time. It's a pretty straight forward way to get multiple cameras in sync without the need for extra sets of hands.

Nov 24, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterDouglas Urner

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>